Fathoming Pakistan's Cycles of Instability
Oct 2007, Vol. 152, No. 5
By Samir Puri
Consensus exists that Pakistan is a linchpin state in regional and global
security matters. However, its multifaceted strategic landscape renders consensus on virtually every other major issue less forthcoming.
History evidences that bouts of instability in Pakistan are cyclical affairs. The country has been here many times before for reasons that appear defined by the specific concerns of their epoch, but arise from surprisingly unchanging root causes. A framework for understanding the degree of hazard or opportunity posed by recent developments is to determine the extent to which they represent continuities or discontinuities with previous trends. Continuity suggests the phenomenon in question has antecedents and therefore outcomes evidenced by past periods of instability, while discontinuity suggests a break with past trends is in the making.
The trend lines dictating Pakistan’s fate are both foreign and domestic – indeed, the blurred line between the two realms is part of the reason why lasting stability in Pakistan has proved so elusive. This article seeks to locate more precisely where along the trough of instability recent events place Pakistan, and will consider just how deep a trough this is likely to prove before the peaks of prosperity and stability can be scaled.
Add your comments
By Samir Puri
Consensus exists that Pakistan is a linchpin state in regional and global
security matters. However, its multifaceted strategic landscape renders consensus on virtually every other major issue less forthcoming.
History evidences that bouts of instability in Pakistan are cyclical affairs. The country has been here many times before for reasons that appear defined by the specific concerns of their epoch, but arise from surprisingly unchanging root causes. A framework for understanding the degree of hazard or opportunity posed by recent developments is to determine the extent to which they represent continuities or discontinuities with previous trends. Continuity suggests the phenomenon in question has antecedents and therefore outcomes evidenced by past periods of instability, while discontinuity suggests a break with past trends is in the making.
The trend lines dictating Pakistan’s fate are both foreign and domestic – indeed, the blurred line between the two realms is part of the reason why lasting stability in Pakistan has proved so elusive. This article seeks to locate more precisely where along the trough of instability recent events place Pakistan, and will consider just how deep a trough this is likely to prove before the peaks of prosperity and stability can be scaled.
You need 4 credits to access this item
If you are a member or registered user, please login
Not already a member and have not yet registered?
Add your comments
Copyright © 2009 RUSI